Monday, 19 October 2026

JUDICIAL GOVERNANCE OF GHANA: CONSTITUTIONAL REVIEW REPORT [ VOL 2.]


               In accordance to the Constitutional review report, and citing from B4.96 to B4.109, depicts a narration of notion; presumed by the Committee, as the principles of Judicial Administrative practices of the Ghana Court, categorized into Judicial leadership and the General Administrative authority, vested into a single office of the Chief Justice, with a conception that, the 1992 Constitution of the Fourth Republic, has failed to establish safeguard rules, to control arbitrary powers of the apex Court, thereby, risking the entire Administrative management system of the Court, into an  individual autonomy, and discretionary decision mistakes.

                A careful analysis of the cited argument of the Constitutional review report, from B4.97 on the Administrative powers of the Chief Justice, for case allocation and empanelment of Justices and Judges, transfer of Judicial officers, oversight of Court registries, and Court administration; the question raised by the author is, could there be any set-out rules of Constitutional text of construct, beyond the existing text of the 1992 Constitution, as a response onto the ever-changing Administrative duties of the Judiciary Court, examining the concerns raised by the report? If, there is, then, I will assure the Committee, it never a Constitutional review, but a legislative instrument or statute analysis.

                In furtherance, the argument as submitted by the review report, citing B4.98; as core Administrative work of the Judiciary, with the empanelment of Judges to cases, and Court management, which fall in the rudiment of Judicial administrative rules, and demands an experience leadership, of a competent Judicial officer: Could there be any provision of the Constitution, as a best fit rules, to govern such actions? I am tempted to belief, the Committee failed to appreciate, the essence, and emphasis, on the rigorous in Constitutional procedural requirement, towards the appointment of a Chief Justice, as outlined in Article 144 (1) of the 1992 Constitution, as put-forward in the Vol.1 of this paper.

               Establishing, the defense of refute against the Constitutional review report, on B4.98  and B4.99, I  argue, it impossible to produce a Constitutional text of rules, to fluid Administrative power; the essence of Statutes,  as legislative instrument for  Administrative rules, to allow for reasonable time period amendment. Secondly, the relevance of competent personnel to assume such offices, appreciating the demands, and requisite capacity to discharge the duty, without disappointing it stakeholders. Hence, the emphasis to address the concerns raised, if, there is any, is the Appointment suitability and  Procedural audit to the Office of Chief Justice, under the checks and balances of Government, by the Constitution, as put forwards by the Vol.1 of the author’s paper.

                  In accordance to the Constitutional review report, citing from B4.101, which disagrees with the Constitutional provision of Article 136,  Section (1a), (1b) and (1c), as well Article 139, Section (1a), (1b) and (1c); as inappropriateness to the Court, to the Judges hierarchy, deny Institutional autonomy, and blurs Institutional boundaries, with the opinion that, it can create uncertainty regarding decisions of the independence of Judges, at lower levels, in relation to administrative oversight; In  annexed to the review report of B4.102; I am persuaded, the Constitutional review report, on the subject matter, seems to narrate the prejudice relating to Judicial Administrative concerns, rather, than the substantive facts governing the domain.

                The rhetorical questions in citing from B4.101 is, could the Judges, at the High Court, or the Appeal Court, operate as Institutional autonomy, independent from the Supreme Court, and the Chief Justice? If  so, as proposed, then, do Ghana have a Judicial system? If, the argument, is to relief the Chief Justice from those Courts, in contravention to Article 136 and 139 of the 1992 Constitution, then, who do Ghanaians hold liable as gatekeeper of the Court, when there is a manifested incompetence of a Judge, leading to a miscarriage of Justice, for the people of Ghana?

               Does the statement of Article 136 (1a), (1b), and (1c) thou quote,

“ (1) The Court of Appeal shall consist of -

(a) the Chief Justice

 

(b) subject to clauses (2) and (3) of this article, not less than ten

Justices of the Court of Appeal; and

 

(c) such other Justices of the Superior Court of Judicature as the

Chief Justice may, for the determination of a particular cause or

matter by writing signed by him, request to sit in the Court of

                              Appeal for any specified period.”                                                                                

Do the phrase in quote,  translate in the Committee’s reviews report, as the required direct presence of the Chief Justice, nor blurs Institutional boundaries, as well deny Institutional autonomy? If  so, then, it has to be admitted, the Committee’s seem to me, they lack understanding of how the Judicial Administrative Court system work, more so, the framework of how the Anglo-American legal system function, upon which the 1992 Constitution, holds it prototype model. The defense argument in favour of the 1992 Constitution, subject the Constitutional review report, citing B4.103, B4.104 and B4.105  for nuanced scrutiny, and re-consideration.

             If, the Committee review report, citing B4.107, B4.108, B4.109; is worthy of critical consideration, then, will refer the Committee to acquaint themselves of Article 154 of the 1992 Constitution, on the functions of the Judicial Council, towards the Administrative governance of the Chief Justice. And proceed to Article 157, on the Rules of  the Court Committee, in addition to  Article 159; which establishes the safeguard rules, towards the governance of the Chief Justice, for the Administrative purposes of the Court, to discharge Justice, for the people of Ghana.

                    I, thou, shall indulge the Constitutional Committee, to reconsider their recommendation, citing B4.110;  it struggles with inherent contradictions, and rather exult the text of the 1992 Constitution, for the Administrative power of the Chief Justice, hence, shall ask the following questions, on the Committee’s amendment recommendation, for re-consideration. The recommended amendment of B4.110 (1) to B4.110 (2b) under the principles of Judicial Administration  does it not contradict itself ? The amendment recommendation of B4.110 (3a), does the proposed President of the Appeal Court, in the spirit of  Institutional autonomy, grant the Office, a Constitutional obligation to the cases or to the Staffs?

Does the required qualification of knowledge, and experience of being a Registrar to the Court, sufficient to empanel Justices, better than the Chief Justice?

And who do we hold liable in the accountability of the  impaneled Justices, if they fail to discharge their duty, of competency to the Court ? The Registrar or the Chief Justice ?

These questions stated above, are meant to interrogate the recommended amendment, by the Constitutional committee review report, for Judicial Governance.

 ______________________________           

Emmanuel Tweneboah Senzu, Sir William Blackstone Chair professor of Law, Oxford University fellow. Fulbright fellow J. Reuben Clark Law School, Brigham Young University, Utah, United States. Distinguished fellow, Ghana School of Law.

 

             

No comments:

Post a Comment

POPULAR ARTICLES OF LAW

RECENT ARTICLES OF LAW

THE REGIONAL TRIBUNAL: CONSTITUTIONAL REVIEW REPORT

  The question pending before the 1992 Constitution of the Fourth Republic ,  in relation to Tribunal Institutionalization, for the people o...