The response of this paper, on the procedural dismiss, of the Justices of the Superior Court, and or the Chief Justice, as a volume (3) brief, to the recommendation of the Constitutional Committee’s review report; I did refuse to grant a rebuttal views, on the Commentaries of the Committee’s report, citing from B4.119 to B4.141; and rather, opted to address the cardinal issue, pertinent to the concerns, which will complement in setting-out the Constitutional rules objectively, in response to the demands of changing times, per the review of the phrasal constructs, to Article 146 of the 1992 Constitution, Section (3), (4), (5), (6) and (7).
However, wholly concur with the Committee recommendation, citing from B4.142, on the grounds of removal of the Justices of the Superior Court, and or the Chief Justice, as stipulated by the Constitution, pursuant to Article 146, Section (1), to be a universal applied conditions, for the Judges of all the Courts in Ghana, either the Upper Court or the Lower Court. Furthermore, do agree with the recommendation, citing B4.142(a), contrary to Article 146, Section (3) and (6), which, I quote;
(3) “ If the President receives a petition for the removal of Justice of a Superior Court, other than the Chief Justice, or for the removal of the Chairman of a Regional Tribunal, he shall refer the petition to the Chief Justice, who shall determine whether there is a prima facie case.”
(6) “ Where the petition is for the removal of the Chief Justice, the President shall, acting in consultation with the Council of State, appoint a committee consisting of two Justices of the Supreme Court, one of whom shall be appointed chairman by the President, and three other persons who are not members of the Council of State, nor members of Parliament, nor lawyers.”
Thou, the recommendation for the confidential petition, to dismiss a Justice of a Superior Court, and or a Chief Justices, as a matter of procedure, is to be channeled to the Chairman of the Council of State, rather than the President, is a reasonable view, in good standing to the spirit of the Constitution, in contemporary governance; it shield the Executive Office, from perceptive manipulation attacks, under a political agenda, of candidature choices, for the Court. While the lower Court disciplinary sanctions, in purview of Judicial Council, and in accordance to the 1992 Constitution, is justifiable. However, the critical emphasis to the author’s argument, submitting herein, is to have a defined procedure, governing the content of Petition, qualified to invoke State apparatus, to avoid waste of precious government time, and limited resources, for investigation of no merit.
The recommendation therein, should be a set-out standard of rules, as litmus test of evidence, to guide the admittance of cases by the Chairman of the Council of State, on the subject of Judicial disciplinary sanctions, as prima facie merit: Before the Council of State Chamber, shall proceed to constitute, a Committee of investigative body or a Tribunal to establish the Substance and Form of the Case, on behalf of Government, for a dismissal of the Culprit.
The structure in constituting the Tribunal, as proposed by the Constitutional review committee report, for disciplinary sanctions of the Justices of the Superior Court, and or the Chief Justice, per an indicted petition, against their candidature and Office, I object not, thou, consider it justifiable, for the spirit of the Constitution.
______________________________
Emmanuel Tweneboah Senzu, Sir William Blackstone Chair professor of Law, Oxford University fellow. Fulbright fellow J. Reuben Clark Law School, Brigham Young University, Utah, United States. Distinguished fellow, Ghana School of Law.



